Bid Tracking for Cabinet Shops
In this guide
- Why bid tracking for cabinet shops pays off
- What to track for every bid
- Bid log columns: a spreadsheet template
- How to calculate bid win rate
- Go/no-go criteria: which jobs to bid
- Bid follow-up: a simple cadence
- Using lost bid data to improve pricing
- When to move from a spreadsheet to bid tracking software
- Frequently asked questions
Bid tracking for cabinet shops means keeping one record of every job you are invited to bid, every bid you send, and what happened to it: won, lost, or never decided. Done well, it tells you which customers to chase, which jobs to pass on, and whether your pricing is winning the work you actually want.
Most shops bid more work than they win, and the bids they lose carry as much information as the ones they win. This guide covers what to log, how to calculate your bid win rate, how to decide which jobs to bid, how to follow up, and when a spreadsheet stops being enough.
Why bid tracking for cabinet shops pays off
Every bid costs estimator time. A residential kitchen might take a few hours to price. A commercial casework package with specs, addenda and a dozen elevation sheets can take days. If you are not tracking bids, you cannot see where that time goes or what it returns.
A good bid log answers questions an owner asks every month:
- What is due this week, and who is working on it?
- What did we send that is still open, and when did we last follow up?
- Which GCs, builders and designers do we actually win work from?
- Are we losing on price, or on something else?
- Is our backlog going to be full in three months?
None of that requires software. It requires a habit of logging every invitation and every outcome.
What to track for every bid
Log the job when the invitation arrives, not when you decide to bid. Declined invitations are data too.
Invitation details
- Date received and who sent it.
- Customer: general contractor, builder, designer, homeowner or owner direct.
- Project name, location and type (single family kitchen, multifamily, office TI, school, healthcare, lab).
- Bid due date and time, and the job walk or pre-bid date if there is one.
- Where the documents live (plan room, link, email) and the addenda count.
Bid details
- Go or no-go decision and the reason.
- Estimator assigned.
- Scope included and excluded (casework, countertops, install, hardware, appliances).
- Bid amount and your estimated cost, so you can see margin.
- Date submitted.
Outcome details
- Status: open, won, lost, no decision, withdrawn.
- Follow-up dates and what was said.
- Award date and winning number, if the customer will share it.
- Win or loss reason, in a few words.
Bid log columns: a spreadsheet template
If you track bids in a spreadsheet, these columns cover what most cabinet shops need. Keep one row per bid per customer. When you bid the same project to three GCs, that is three rows, because each one can be won or lost separately.
| Column | Example entry | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Bid ID | 2026-114 | One reference for files, emails and the estimate |
| Date received | 2026-10-02 | Measures response time and volume |
| Customer | Acme Builders | Win rate by customer |
| Contact | Project estimator name | Who to follow up with |
| Project | Elm St. Apartments | Groups bids to multiple GCs |
| Project type | Multifamily | Win rate by market |
| Due date | 2026-10-16 2:00 PM | Drives the weekly schedule |
| Go / no-go | Go | Shows what you pass on |
| Estimator | Initials | Workload and accountability |
| Scope notes | Casework and tops, no install | Explains price differences |
| Bid amount | (your number) | Win rate by dollars |
| Estimated cost | (your number) | Margin on bids won and lost |
| Submitted | 2026-10-16 | Confirms on-time submission |
| Status | Open / Won / Lost / No decision | The core of the log |
| Last follow-up | 2026-10-23 | Prevents bids going cold |
| Next follow-up | 2026-11-06 | Your follow-up queue |
| Result date | 2026-11-20 | Sales cycle length |
| Winning number | If shared | Calibrates pricing |
| Win / loss reason | Price, schedule, relationship | Tells you what to fix |
Keep the status and reason columns to a short fixed list (a dropdown in the spreadsheet). Free text is impossible to count later. A cabinet estimate template pairs well with this log: the estimate holds the details, the log holds the pipeline.
How to calculate bid win rate
Bid win rate, also called hit rate, is the share of submitted bids you win. The simplest version is wins divided by bids submitted. A more useful version divides by bids that have actually been decided, and you should calculate it both by count and by dollars, because they tell you different things.
Win rate by count
Win rate by count = bids won / bids decided
Win rate by dollars
Win rate by dollars = dollar value of bids won / dollar value of bids decided
Use bids that have been decided (won or lost) as the denominator. Bids that are still open, and bids where the project never went ahead, distort the number. Track the "no decision" pile separately; if it is large, your customers are using you for budget numbers.
Worked example
Example numbers only; use your own data. Over a quarter a shop submits 40 bids. Ten are still open and two projects were cancelled, so 28 were decided. The shop won 7.
- Win rate by count: 7 / 28 = 25%.
- The 28 decided bids totalled $1,400,000. The 7 wins totalled $210,000.
- Win rate by dollars: $210,000 / $1,400,000 = 15%.
The dollar rate is lower than the count rate, so this shop is winning smaller jobs and losing larger ones. That is worth a look: is it pricing large jobs too high, competing against larger shops on capacity, or bidding big jobs it does not really want?
Slice the numbers
Once you have a few months of data, break win rate down by customer, project type, bid size range and estimator. A shop might find it wins steadily with two builders and almost never with a GC it bids for every month. That changes where estimating time should go.
Go/no-go criteria: which jobs to bid
Bidding everything feels safe, but it spreads estimators thin and lowers the quality of every bid. A simple go/no-go checklist, applied to every invitation, protects your time. Score each question yes or no, and set a bar for how many yeses you need.
- Is this our kind of work: residential, commercial casework, or the mix we build well?
- Can we deliver in the schedule shown, given our current backlog?
- Have we won work from this customer before, or do we have a real relationship?
- Do we know who else is bidding, and can we compete with them?
- Are the documents complete enough to price without guessing?
- Is the bid due date realistic for the size of the takeoff?
- Can we meet the spec requirements: AWS grade, certifications, bonding, insurance?
- Does the customer pay on time?
Log the answers. After a few months, compare the go/no-go scores of the jobs you won with the jobs you lost. If you rarely win jobs that scored low, you can raise the bar and stop spending time on them.
Bid follow-up: a simple cadence
Bid follow up is where many shops leave work on the table. A follow-up is not a sales pitch. It is a check that your bid was received, a chance to answer questions, and a way to learn the outcome. Here is a cadence that works for many shops; adjust to the customer.
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| Same day as submission | Confirm the bid was received and is complete |
| A few days after bid day | Ask if there are scope questions or clarifications needed |
| One to two weeks later | Ask about the timeline for award |
| Around the expected award date | Ask for the result |
| After the result | Ask for feedback: where you landed and why |
Log every touch with the date and what was said. On commercial work, the GC is often waiting on the owner's award, so a polite check every couple of weeks is fine. On residential work, a homeowner or designer comparing bids may decide quickly, so follow up within days.
Using lost bid data to improve pricing
A lost bid tells you something only if you ask why. Ask every time, and record the reason in your log using a fixed list:
- Price: we were higher.
- Scope: we priced more or less than others.
- Schedule: we could not meet the dates.
- Relationship: the customer went with their usual sub.
- Qualifications: we did not meet a spec or bonding requirement.
- Project cancelled or on hold.
When a customer shares the winning number or where you ranked, record it. Over time you can see patterns. If you are consistently high on plastic laminate casework but competitive on residential kitchens, look at your labor rates, material yields and overhead for that work. Compare your bid to your estimated cost, not just to the winner. Sometimes the right answer is to keep your price and stop bidding that work.
Be careful with small samples. A few losses on price do not prove you are too expensive. Look at trends across many bids before changing rates. Our guide on how to price custom cabinets covers building rates you can defend.
When to move from a spreadsheet to bid tracking software
A spreadsheet bid log works for a single estimator and a manageable volume. These are signs it is time for construction bid tracking software, or for an estimating tool with bid tracking built in:
- More than one estimator is updating the log and versions collide.
- Follow-ups are missed because nobody is reminded.
- You cannot connect a bid in the log to the estimate and drawings behind it.
- Re-bids and revisions after addenda are hard to keep straight.
- You want win rate by customer or project type without building pivot tables by hand.
When you evaluate bid tracking software, look for due-date reminders, follow-up tasks, status and loss reasons as structured fields, a link from each bid to its estimate and takeoff, and reports by customer and project type. The cabinet estimating software buyer's guide covers what to ask vendors.
CabinetHub keeps tracking in the same place as the estimate: a shop uploads a plan set, receives an estimator-reviewed takeoff, prices it with its own rates and margin, sends the bid to its customer and tracks it from there.
Frequently asked questions
What is bid tracking?
Bid tracking is keeping a record of every bid invitation, bid submitted and outcome, along with due dates, amounts, follow-ups and win or loss reasons. It lets a shop manage deadlines, follow up on open bids and measure its win rate.
How do you calculate a bid win rate?
Divide the number of bids won by the number of bids decided (won plus lost). Also calculate it by dollars: total value of bids won divided by total value of bids decided. Leave open and cancelled bids out of the denominator.
What should a bid log include?
At minimum: customer, project, bid due date, estimator, bid amount, estimated cost, date submitted, status, follow-up dates, result and the win or loss reason. Keep status and reason as a short fixed list so you can count them.
How often should you follow up on a bid?
Confirm receipt the day you submit, check for questions a few days later, then follow up every week or two until the award. Always ask for feedback on the result, win or lose.
What is a good bid win rate for a cabinet shop?
There is no single benchmark. Win rate depends on market, customer mix and how selective you are about what you bid. Track your own rate over time and compare it across customers, project types and bid sizes.